Skip to content
Mention Science.

Category Web Presence Correlates With Which Brands ChatGPT Puts in Its Fanout Queries

Antony Deroshan

By Antony Deroshan

Co-founder at Mention Science

10 min read

When ChatGPT uses web search, it doesn’t search for the user’s words. It writes its own fanout queries—and often puts brand names straight into them.

For “best email marketing software”, the live fanout query was best email marketing software 2026 Mailchimp Kit beehiiv HubSpot official pricing features.

So which brands get written in? And why does ChatGPT leave out brands it clearly knows?

We compared 919 live ChatGPT fanout queries with a fanout query simulator, then checked every brand against the January 2026 Common Crawl to find out.

ChatGPT fanout queries only name a shortlist of brands, and the order of that shortlist tracks how much of the web mentions each brand in its category.

Here’s what we found…

Key takeaways

  • 85% of live ChatGPT fanout queries name at least one brand (782 of 919).
  • ChatGPT knows brands it still leaves out. Campaign Monitor came up from memory on 49 of 50 email prompts, but appeared in just 1 of 50 live fanout queries.
  • Fanout queries only have room for a short list of brands. Brands left out of the live query come back when the simulator is allowed to name 8 or 12.
  • Category web presence correlates with the order. Brands mentioned on more websites alongside their category enter the shortlist earlier (0.76 rank match across 29 brands).
  • On a category we set aside before looking at the results, the match was 0.986.
  • General fame doesn’t decide it. Sony has more mentions overall, but Canon has more on camera pages—and Canon enters the shortlist first.

85% of ChatGPT fanout queries name a brand

Out of 919 live ChatGPT fanout queries, 782 named at least one brand.

That’s 85%.

And the brands are chosen before any page comes back. The fanout query is what gets sent to the search indexes, so the pages that return are already about the brands it named.

In other words, if your brand isn’t in the fanout query, the pages about you never get asked for.

ChatGPT leaves out brands it already knows

The obvious explanation for a missing brand is that ChatGPT doesn’t know it.

So we tested that. With web search off, we asked the model which brands came to mind for 50 unbranded prompts per category.

Then we compared that with how often each brand appeared in the live fanout queries:

Mention Science research: named from memory vs. in the live fanout query, out of 50 prompts: Campaign Monitor 49 vs 1, Basecamp 45 vs 0, Hasselblad 44 vs 0, AWeber 23 vs 0, ClickUp 50 vs 29.

Campaign Monitor came up from memory on 49 of 50 email prompts. It appeared in 1 live fanout query.

Basecamp came up on 45 of 50 project management prompts, and Hasselblad on 44 of 50 camera prompts. Neither appeared in a single live fanout query.

So these brands aren’t unknown, and they aren’t banned. Something else is keeping them out.

Fanout queries only have room for a shortlist of brands

ChatGPT doesn’t let anyone change how many brands go into a fanout query. Our simulator does.

We required the simulated fanout query to name exactly 1, 2, 3, 5, 8 or 12 brands, and recorded the smallest number at which each brand first appeared.

Here’s what that looks like for email marketing tools:

Email marketing brands: how often each appears in live ChatGPT fanout queries, and the smallest brand budget at which it enters the simulated fanout query
BrandIn live fanout queriesEnters the simulator at
Mailchimp39 of 501 brand
Constant Contact3 of 502 brands
ActiveCampaign16 of 505 brands
Brevo28 of 505 brands
Klaviyo18 of 508 brands
Campaign Monitor1 of 508 brands
GetResponse0 of 508 brands
AWeber0 of 5012 brands
MailerLite5 of 5012 brands
ConvertKit1 of 50Not in at 12

The brands missing from the live fanout queries came back once the simulator had room for them.

AWeber appeared in 2 of 50 simulated queries at a budget of 8, and 47 of 50 at 12. Campaign Monitor jumped from 1 of 50 at 5 to 43 of 50 at 8.

The same thing happened outside email. Basecamp enters at 8, and Hasselblad at 12.

To me, that suggests the live fanout query writer works from a ranked list and cuts it short. Brands below the cutoff are left out—not because they’re unknown, but because they’re further down the list.

Category web presence correlates with which brands make the shortlist

So what decides the order?

We counted how many websites mention each brand near words about its category, using the January 2026 Common Crawl. Then we ranked each brand only against rivals in the same category.

The brands with more category web presence entered the shortlist earlier:

Mention Science research: websites mentioning each email brand near email-software words in the January 2026 Common Crawl, and the brand budget at which each enters the simulated fanout query. Mailchimp leads with 53,793 websites and enters at 1.

Mailchimp has 53,793 websites mentioning it alongside email software—3.5x more than ActiveCampaign, its nearest rival. It’s also the first email brand in, at a budget of 1.

The same pattern holds in every category we tested. The brand with the most category web presence is the first brand into the simulated fanout query, at a budget of 1:

The category leader by web presence in each category, where it enters the simulated fanout query, and how often it appears in live ChatGPT fanout queries
CategoryLeader by web presenceWebsitesEnters the simulator atIn live fanout queries
EmailMailchimp53,7931 brand39 of 50
CRMSalesforce29,3241 brand35 of 50
HelpdeskZendesk3,2561 brand35 of 49
Password managers1Password8,4831 brand42 of 50
Project managementAsana10,4371 brand38 of 50
CamerasCanon42,1021 brand43 of 50

Across all 29 brands, the within-category rankings match at 0.76. For the 25 brands that enter the simulator, it’s 0.85.

And on e-signature tools—a category we fixed in advance as a test—the match was 0.986. DocuSign is first by web presence, and first in the simulated fanout query.

Category mentions matter more than general fame

Count every mention of each brand, and Sony beats Canon.

Count only mentions on camera pages, and Canon beats Sony (42,102 websites vs. 34,849). Canon also enters the simulated fanout query first.

None of this is a big surprise. A brand that the web constantly talks about in a category is the brand a model learns to name for that category.

How to get your brand into ChatGPT’s fanout queries

So, what does all of this data actually mean?

In short, ChatGPT picks a shortlist of brands before it reads a single page, and that shortlist follows category web presence.

1. Check whether you’re in the fanout query

Run the prompts your buyers actually ask, and look at the fanout queries ChatGPT writes—not just the final answer.

If your brand isn’t in the fanout query, the answer starts without you.

2. Earn mentions in your category, not just mentions

Pages that name your brand next to your category’s words are what tracked shortlist position.

Reviews, comparisons, “best of” roundups and directories in your space are where those mentions live. Digital PR that lands you on them is worth more than generic brand coverage.

3. Measure your gap against category rivals

Shortlist position is relative. What matters is how your category web presence compares with the brands you compete with.

Track the gap to the brands just above you, not a raw mention count.

How our data compares to other studies

Suganthan Mohanadasan’s study found that brands named in a live fanout query are cited about 69% of the time, while brands that only show up later, on the pages, are cited about 2% of the time.

Our follow-up study measured the same question at scale:

Fanout-to-answer rates across studies
StudySampleFanout brands that reach the answer
Mention Science108,396 brands71.4%
Suganthan Mohanadasan119 brands68.9%

Both point the same way. Being written into the fanout query is the strongest position a brand can be in.

This study explains which brands get that position.

Methodology

We ran four steps.

1. Live fanout queries

We extracted 919 live ChatGPT fanout queries from the API, each with the prompt it came from. 782 of them named at least one brand.

2. A fanout query simulator

We built a simulator on GPT-5.6 Luna. It receives the same prompt with web search turned off, plus one fixed instruction: write the web search ChatGPT would write.

Then we compared each simulated fanout query with the live one:

Mention Science research: simulated and live ChatGPT fanout queries shared at least one brand on 92.3% of prompts, the same set of brands on 12.8%, and the same wording on 0%.

The simulator never copied the live wording, and it rarely produced the exact same set of brands. But it shared at least one brand with the live query on 722 of 782 prompts.

Across a fixed panel of brands, how often each brand appears lines up with the live fanout queries at 0.965.

That agreement is what makes the simulator useful for the question the live system won’t answer.

Compare live and simulated fanout queries on 10 prompts
Brands in the live and simulated fanout queries, and how many live brands the simulator also picked
PromptLive fanout querySimulated fanout queryMatched
best email marketing softwareMailchimp, Kit, beehiiv, HubSpotMailchimp, Brevo, Constant Contact, HubSpot, ActiveCampaign2 of 4
best email marketing software 2026Mailchimp, Kit, Brevo, HubSpot, ActiveCampaign, KlaviyoMailchimp, HubSpot, Brevo, Constant Contact, Klaviyo4 of 6
best CRM softwareSalesforce, HubSpot, Zoho, PipedriveSalesforce, HubSpot, Zoho CRM, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Pipedrive4 of 4
best CRM software 2026Salesforce, HubSpot, Zoho, Microsoft Dynamics 365, PipedriveSalesforce, HubSpot, Zoho CRM, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Pipedrive5 of 5
best helpdesk softwareZendesk, Freshdesk, Intercom, Help Scout, Zoho Desk, GorgiasZendesk, Freshdesk, Intercom, Help Scout, Gorgias5 of 6
best password manager1Password, Bitwarden, Proton Pass, Dashlane1Password, Bitwarden, Dashlane, NordPass3 of 4
best project management softwareAsana, Monday, ClickUp, Notion, Jira, SmartsheetAsana, Trello, monday.com, ClickUp3 of 6
best VPN serviceNone (review sites only)NordVPN, ExpressVPN, Surfshark, Proton VPN—
best VPN service 2026NordVPN, Surfshark, Proton VPN, WireGuardNordVPN, ExpressVPN, Surfshark, Proton VPN3 of 4
best website builderWix, Squarespace, Shopify, WordPress.com, Webflow, FramerWix, Squarespace, Shopify, Webflow4 of 6

3. A search-off recall test

Separately, we checked whether the model knows each brand without the web:

  • 50 unbranded prompts in each of six categories.
  • Web search off.
  • One added instruction: “List the current brands that come to mind as leading options. Names only.” We alternated its position before and after the prompt.
  • A brand counts when its name or a fixed alias appears anywhere in the answer.

This test doesn’t ask for a fanout query, a ranking or a recommendation. It only measures whether a brand is known for the category.

4. Brand budget and Common Crawl

In the simulator, we required the fanout query to name exactly 1, 2, 3, 5, 8 or 12 brands, and recorded the smallest budget at which each brand appeared.

For web presence, we counted unique websites in the January 2026 Common Crawl where each brand appears near words about its category. We compared rankings only within each category.

Cleaning the crawl didn’t strengthen the match:

Rank match between category web presence and fanout shortlist position, by crawl version
Crawl versionRank match
Raw pages0.762
After the quality filter0.730
After quality filtering and near-duplicate removal0.730

Final thoughts

ChatGPT decides which brands to look up before it reads a single page.

That list is short. Well-known brands still get cut, simply because they sit below the cutoff.

And the order isn’t random. It tracks how often the web mentions each brand in its category.

So the work is the same as it’s always been, with a new reason to do it: get your brand named on more pages about your category.

But, bear in mind, this could all shift again with the next model update. If you have questions about this research, feel free to ping us on LinkedIn.

Antony Deroshan

Post by

Antony Deroshan

Antony Deroshan is the co-founder of Mention Science. Antony studies how AI assistants choose which brands to name, and publishes that research here, starting with how ChatGPT writes its fanout queries.